Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Do you agree or disagree with this statement and why? : "Christianity, then, is NOT the religion OF ...?

Full statement: "Christianity, then, is NOT the religion OF Jesus (as so many Christians think it to be) but the religion ABOUT Jesus, which is an entirely different matter." Do you agree or disagree and why? (Serious answers only please)

Update:

"religion OF Jesus..." means a religion based on that which Jesus lived by and followed, observed, whereas "religion about Jesus..." means a religion based in information ABOUT jesus, who he might have been or was, his life, what he might have done. "religion of..." means that religion which Jesus himself lived by.

12 Answers

Relevance
  • 7 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    I do agree with that; thanks for asking it. It is more a religion about Jesus and not of Jesus. I like to focus on the face that Jesus worshipped God; never claiming that he was God or that he should be worshipped; and nothing of a trinity which some Christians believe. I mean it is that it is a religion in that they speak about him and claim to follow him, but what they are taught is not actually what Jesus lived for and did.

  • 7 years ago

    I'll be safe and say "a little of both?" probably more ABOUT Jesus because the religion kept on going strong after Jesus died, and so he couldn't really add to it. People were continuing to follow Judaism and so that had to have become mixed in. And then of course over the years, as it spread around the world, all kinds of things must have gotten mixed in. I don't think Jesus taught about Santa Claus and giving gifts at Christmas, but here it is. I'm sure you can get scholarly answers. I have recorded still on my TiVo a documentary called "From Jesus to Christ" and it's quite interesting as it traces the progress of Jesus's life and teachings and its end, and all the political stuff that was going on between the Romans and the Jews and the Christians, and then the Greeks getting involved. My my my. I don't think anything comes forth whole cloth when it comes to humans and their beliefs!!

    I don't think it matters, anyway. Your religion is what they taught you when you were a kid. Then you can change it or not, but that's still in the back of your mind as "my religion."

  • 7 years ago

    not so sure it is about Jesus either.

    It is a religion used to justify the accumulation of wealth, the hording of power, the impoverishment of many for the benefit of the few overlords. It was developed by the ROman empire into a religion that approved of conquest by force and of 'might makes right'

    sorry to state it this way but these are the truths. You can't say "oh those earlier Christians DIDN'T UNDERSTAND the way we do today". They understood VERY VERY WELL. "They weren't real Christians." -- I love that one. So the ruthless tax collectors who built Chartres and Notre Dame and Koln, who paid the greatest architects and sculptors of the day to build these fantastic structures -- they were not 'real Christians" - I'm sure they would all be surprised to hear that.

    By the way it is an Army of real Christians today that is leading the battle in the Middle East - many of the US Soldiers there are fiercely Christian and see the wars as a religious undertaking. Something fully supported by the Holy Book.

  • Anonymous
    7 years ago

    Christianity has nothing to do with Yahushua Ha Mashiach, His name was never jesus christ that is all from the rcc.

    Ruth has it right they were called Nazarenes & all that Yahushua taught was about His Fathers Torah, not about Himself.

    Torah is not judaism either. Some more man made theories & addition of 613 laws.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • ?
    Lv 7
    7 years ago

    Definitely. When you read the words of Jesus as presented in the synoptic gospels it becomes clear hat he was preaching about something completely different. He was an apocalyptic preacher warning of a judgment that he thought would be coming very soon. All the dogma and theology of Christianity today was simply made up later by those who wanted a religion about Jesus.

  • 7 years ago

    Christianity comes from catholicism & is not of Y'shua. The group that He started were called Nazarene's & they followed Torah not some manmade religion.

    It is not of Y'shua nor is it about Y'shua.

    Some guy called jesus did not even exist & is also catholic interference with the Word of YHVH & His Messiah. Iesus, some pagan god to do with isis, tammuz, nimrod, so on & so forth. 300 years of meddling with scripture & adding their own demonic, satanic renditions & lies.

    Y'shua lived by Torah & Torah only, according to what His Father in heaven told Him to do.

  • 7 years ago

    yes, christianity is a religion created by man based on paul's letters, and in ,any cases, that jesus was a god or part of a trinity.

    jesus was the messiah and the fulfillment of many jewish prophecies, a torah teacher and a jew himself.

    his followers are messianic jews.

  • Andy W
    Lv 7
    7 years ago

    What does religion about Jesus mean, anyway?

    If it means a relationship with Jesus then yes.

  • Anonymous
    7 years ago

    Christianity is a religion of discrepancies and deciet.

    When you must lie repeatedly to convince people of something, it is clear that the something is also a lie.

    So if anything, christianity is known worldwide as the religion of dishonesty and lies.

    Ain't it nice to know you have made a name for yourselves?

    Right on cue, Apostle James The Greater has posted a pack of lies to back me up. Thanks for that!

  • 7 years ago

    There is always a tension between the two--this is NOT a new concept.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.