Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Is this child neglect?
My friend's boyfriend was sick, causing her to be sick. So she decided to stay home from school. Her mom then made her cancel plans with her boyfriend for the weekend, yelled at her saying that she wasn't sick and just never sleeps enough, and turned of her phone to cut off all communication to her friends. She then pointed out to her mother that when her older brother would miss school, she didn't punish him. Her mother screamed that she knew it was unfair but she shouldn't be missing school because her boyfriend went to school sick (keeping his record of not a single day missed of school his whole high school career). Is this bordering emotional child neglect for isolating her & extreme punishments? Could I report this behavior to somebody?
10 Answers
- jlbLv 75 years ago
Child neglect? No. Isolation? Not having a cell phone or being able to go out for a weekend isn't exactly a human rights violation. The whole situation sounds a little more dramatic than it needs to be, but there isn't anything to report here.
- 5 years ago
No. This is just ordinary discipline. Kids don't need to be in constant contact with their friends, it's a want not a need. Neglect is not meeting a child's needs - not just depriving them of something they want.
If you were to report this to child protection services, they'd just laugh at you and think you're spoiled.
- LaraLv 75 years ago
I am not seeing where this is neglect or abuse.
If she is sick enough to miss school, then she shouldn't be going out on the weekend. And if you aren't sick enough to miss the weekend, you should be going to school. This was the rule for the majority of people I knew. As for turning off her phone, that wasn't necessary but quite possibly she doesn't want her leaving the house when she is supposed to be home sick.
Is the mom being a little unfair and cold? Yes, but she isn't abusing her daughter.
- 5 years ago
No.
The one really inappropriate element I see here is the mom ignoring her
being sick (I'd assume she caught a cold or the flu). But usually this doesn't constitute neglect unless it causes real serious damage. Yes, you can die of the flu in rare cases, but is rare enough that the blame game only starts after the fact.
It sounds like one of these situations where parents take the increasing independence of their older children as personal affront and offense and develop an antagonistic relation over that.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- blackgrumpycatLv 75 years ago
Whilst it sounds a bit of an over reaction, keeping her away from the boyfriend for a weekend and stopping phone use is a good thing. If your friend really is sick, then she needs time to get better without mixing with other sick people and being distracted by her phone. A bit of peace and quiet will do her good.
- 5 years ago
It is Not abuse, or neglect. You are also just hearing yourfriends story. Were you there? Butt out.
- ElLv 45 years ago
Unfortunately parents just being unfair d*cks isn't really considered 'child abuse' by any authority and you'd just get laughed at if you tried to report that.
- Sewciopath17Lv 65 years ago
no it's not. there's probably a lot more to the story that you are unaware of also






