Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

E
Lv 7

Is it possible for a planet's moon to be larger than the planet?

I'm pretty sure that every natural satellite (moon) that we have discovered so far is smaller in size than the planet it orbits. Is it possible for it to be larger and still orbit that planet?

12 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    9 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    My first thought was that the larger object would always be the planet, but if one of these objects were much more dense than the other, the more massive object could be smaller than the less massive object. An object with the same size as Neptune and the same composition as Earth would be smaller and yet more massive than an object which has the same size and composition as Uranus.

  • 9 years ago

    No. That does not seem possible to me. The question is can a larger body orbit a smaller one. For this to happen, the smaller body must be dense in mass while the larger body is light in mass. This might happen if the orbiting body was mostly gas as in some of our gas giant planets. However, using the Earth as the massive body sort of puts limits upon the size of the gas planet which might orbit it as a moon. Given that sort of constraint, I don't think that the gaseous moon would posses enough gravity to retain its gas molecules. As a result, the gases would eventually bleed off into space and the gaseous moon would evaporate/dissipate.

  • 9 years ago

    My first thought was "no, by definition". But the planet vs moon definition isn't by size, it is by mass. Technically, it is by orbital characteristics. The body that wobbles in a trajectory less than its own size is the planet, and the body that obviously moves around the other is the moon.

    In principle it could be possible to have a dense and massive planet with a sparse and geometrically large moon.

    For example, suppose Earth were the dense and massive planet, and suppose the hypothetical moon were of the density of Saturn (about the density of wood), a tenth the density of Earth (about that of cast iron). It is reasonable to use this example, because Earth and Saturn have the most dissimilar densities of all the spherical bodies in the solar system.

    For this moon to be the mass of Earth, its radius would be about 2.15 Earth radii. So if its radius were only 1.1 Earth radii, then its mass would only be about 13% that of Earth. As long as its orbit were close enough that the two body barycenter were still within Earth, you could call it a moon.

    The likelihood of any of this happening is far from possible. Sparse moons like that would need to be gaseous just like Saturn, which would imply that they'd need to form outside of where terrestrial planets form. Also, a gaseous moon like this couldn't remain in-tact, because its own material wouldn't be bound by its own gravity enough to keep it from diffusing away. Plus, the puffy moon damn well better not cross the interlagrangian point between its center and the planet, because if it does, then its gas will fall upward and spiral in toward the planet, much like in star-black hole relationships.

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    Mass is the key determining factor as to where the center of gravity is located. In order for an object with greater volume to orbit one of lesser volume, the one with lesser volume would need to have more mass... if it has more mass and less volume, then it has a much greater density. All the objects in our solar system fit the model of the larger object having greater mass as well, and with very few exceptions, this barycenter is located within the surface of the primary, while the secondaries orbit around the larger body. If you could somehow find a way to condense the mass of the Earth into a volme less than that of the Moon, and kept the mass of both objects the same, the Moon's orbit would not change. But this smaller Earth of equal mass would have a smaller radius. If this radius was too small, the barycenter would lie closer to the 'New Earth' but not necessarily inside of its surface. The two would orbit the barycenter, just like they do now. But in the case of Pluto and Charon, the barycenter lies outside of both objects.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Irv S
    Lv 7
    9 years ago

    Barely, but it would be extremely odd.

    The more massive body would be the 'planet', and the lighter one

    would orbit around it.

    The densities would have to be very different indeed for a moon to be larger

    than it's 'primary'.

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, it is possible. If the moon is larger but much less massive than the planet. The less massive object orbits the more massive object.

    .

  • No. By definition, a satellite is smaller than its planet. The closest case is Pluto and its moon, Charon. They are quite close in mass, and this is one of the excuses for demoting Pluto from Planet to Dwarf Planet status.

  • 9 years ago

    If by larger you mean circumference, sure, why not? You could have a small rocky body like the Earth in orbit with a slightly bigger gas giant type planet. The Earth like planet would weigh much more than the gas giant, so technically the gas giant would be a moon of the Earth like planet. There's no such examples in our solar system, but I don't see why it wouldn't be possible.

  • Mike
    Lv 5
    9 years ago

    Nope, the reason the moon orbit that planet is because it is larger, and thus, has more gravity.

    It would be impossible to have a moon larger than the planet it revolves around. The smaller will get caught in the gravitational pull of the larger planet.

  • 9 years ago

    Yes.

    If the satellite is more massive but has less density than the planet and if it's barycenter lies within the surface of the planet then it will look bigger than the planet but it will orbit the planet.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.