Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Critique for my story?

I am writing a historical and going over the rough draft I found a passage that I really didn't like but it still got the point across. Can someone critique this, give any ideas on how to make it better, mainly regarding the phrasing.

"Have you heard from Josephine lately?" She asked within one of his pauses.

"No, I'm afraid not. She seldom writes to me." He looked out the window, and then turned back toward Ardellia, "She must be enjoying France." He chuckled under his breath.

"Send my best to her the next time you write."

"She seemed so frail the last time I saw her. I do hope the French air will do her good."

"You speak of her as if she's a child. She is fine, and will be fine." "I still think of her as one. She was running around in the grass only two years ago, and driving her nanny to tears. Do you remember her, Catherine was her name?"

"Yes, why?" Answered Ardellia after a few moments. She eyed him curiously, wondering as to where he meant to go with the change of subject.

"I was only wondering what became of her."

The Mr. and Mrs. Harrison Cleureleis and their daughter Catherine had been with the Van Der Argéns family for years, but the Countess was hardly familiar with even their names. Ten months into the former Ardellia Granham's marriage into the family, the mother and daughter disapeared.

"I remember rumours that they had been seen in several other counties. "

"Following in Slater' s footsteps no doubt... Harrison Cleuruleis was absolutely devastated."

"As would any man be, losing wife and child simultaneously."

"He refused to think that they simply left Sophia and Catherine, he was driven mad with the thought." "No, I did not. What became of him Edmund? I haven't seen anything of him recently."

"I recall that he ended his service two or three years ago."

"Oh?"

"Yes, apparently he was to be remarried."

"At that age, to whom?"

"I do not know."

Update:

My main concern is the housekeeper side story, I really want a better way to introduce it.

Update 2:

What can you tell about these characters from reading this?

Update 3:

The eyed curiously part is her reaction to her husband's odd behaviour that was mentioned earlier on. Because her husband isn't really a talker and she's suspicious of where he's going with the conversation.

My main problem with this is that the dialogue seems forced to me.

3 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Really good so far, just needs a little more emphasise on character emotions :)

    Answer mine?

    http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AvHly...

  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    Okay, first off I want to say that the passage definitely has potential. Some main concerns are that the dialogue seems a little forced and unnatural in parts and the big chunk of back story in the middle really interrupts the flow of the conversation. I think if you want to introduce the back story here then it would be better to actually do it within the dialogue. You really don't want to use summary anymore than you have to; it's always better to "show" than to "tell".

    Also, when Ardellia says, "Yes, why?" in the tag you don't really need anything after "She eyed him curiously". The fact that she's asking why and that she's eyeing him curiously already show what she's thinking so there's no need to explain it.

    All in all, I think it's a good start and with a bit of work it could be really great.

  • 8 years ago

    Looks good to me :) I like it. Just one thing, the second last line has bad grammar. It's "At that age? To whom?" Other than that I really like the housekepper side story

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.