DS: What's your opinion on dogs as "gifts"?

Normally I say it's a bad idea - however, although you're looking to gift her - you're looking to involve her, including respecting her wishes if she says it's a no go.

Given what you've said - it seems like this might be an exception to the rule. Most folks when they gift a puppy, they don't really consider the other person's capability or schedule, much less involve them in choosing the puppy and in the final decision. You're also going to be there for the first few months when potty breaks need to come at shorter intervals. one of the other problems many people fail to consider.

As long as she decides with you she's ready for the commitment timewise, and will have the funds for vet care, good food, and accessories, I don't see an issue in this case.

Though your roommate has the financial part down, how do you know she even wants a puppy just because she has an hour lunch break? I know you said you would be there the first three months, but I still say it's a no go!

Why? Many people like choosing their own dogs and it may be a different dog than what you are trying to bring home to make her feel better. Terrible idea because even though the person loves your dog and says something about getting a new dog, does not mean you go and take them to meet random puppies from a friend.

I know you mean well, but it probably won't work out as you thought it might do. Maybe I'm just grouchy because I hate surprises, especially when it involves animals. What I'm saying is......she may be financially ready, not mentally ready....even though she loves your dog and spends time with it.

I don't agree with it generally. Though there are cases where it is OK.. It just depends a lot on the individuals and the scenario.

For example. Someone buying their friend a dog for Xmas without the person even expressing they wanted a dog, they just assumed they did, is not ok. The person receiving the gift might not even want the dog, and will most likely have no clue about the breed or dog care in general. The person receiving the dog will be the one ultimately paying for it as well.

Another thing is, is that a lot of people like a certain breed, have done the research on a certain breed and want to pick their own dog out. When someone gives them a random dog, they're stuck with it unless they choose to adopt it out... and the breed/mix they receive might be something they can't handle or have no knowledge about.

An OK scenario is if someone decides to pay for the dog's initial cost, but they GO with their friend/daughter/sister etc. to a shelter or breeder to pick out a dog or talk about it beforehand, rather than actually physically buying the dog themselves and surprising the person with the said dog. .

I hope that made sense.

I'm terrible at explaining stuff like this.

I am in favour of making a gift of the purchase price, which then allows the recipient to choose a pet dog that fits their requirements, personality, experience and lifestyle.

Your roommate has expressed an interest in purchasing a pet dog, is in a financial position to meet the cost and you would be offering her the choice of taking on a puppy if she finds one that is suitable and not presenting it sight unseen as a gift, which is something I do not agree with.

Nice idea and responsibly thought through before making the offer.

maximum dental products are gimmicky. In nature, canines sparkling their teeth via chewing on uncooked meaty bones. RMB grant the enzymes and scraping action canines ought to shop their teeth sparkling. we'd actual help the organic technique via brushing their teeth, and having a dental carried out while mandatory. some breeds, particularly small breeds, would want greater effective dental care using being predisposed for dental issues. For those breeds, dental sprays, as nicely to chewing and combing, can help. So: a million. for many canines, no, they do no longer look to be needed. For small breeds, and specific desires canines, sprays would be a helpful gadget. 2. No, i do no longer use them on my canines. 3. ultimate thank you to attend to dental wellness is each and daily brushing, a uncooked bone as quickly as each and every week, and a dental at your vet each and every 3-5 years or as mandatory.

I only see it as a good idea if the person wants a Dog, and if so if it`s the kind of Dog they like (Like I would NOT like it if some one bought me a Shih Tzu).

Sounds like you don't wish to hear a second opinion, huh.

If she truly wanted a dog, she would have bought one herself.

I am a big fan of horses, have always wanted at least two of my own....if some idiot was to purchase me a horse I would be PISSED/

Dogs aren't 3 month only commitments, they are for LIFE.

Not only that, but you plan on purchasing her an unpredictable genetic nightmare as well!!

SCRAP IT.

from what you have said then it's a good idea