Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Do you really believe an adopted child will live a fairytale life??

So many times on a question about abortion many people will say "Give the child up for adoption." Yes, there are good families that want a child but do you really believe that EVERY child given up for adoption will have a good life? A lot of times the child goes through the system for years suffering with people who adopt for money, people who will abuse and mistreat them. Also, to carry a child for so long to just "GIVE" the baby up is not an easy thing to do.

12 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    While I'm a big supporter of adoption and have close friends of the family who are going through the difficult process of adoption, I understand that you are right. Not every child lives a great life when adopted. A friend of mine was adopted when his parents thought they couldn't conceive. Then their miracle baby came along and my friend was all of a sudden no where near as important to them as his brother. His father abused him and his mother would actually rub it in his face that he was adopted and lucky to even have a family.

    Now that he is grown and out of the house though, he is happy and doing just great. I do believe that even though his life may not have been ideal, it was better than having been aborted as a fetus. He agrees.

    It sounds like what you are against is people who say to give a baby up for adoption if the circumstances aren't perfect. Several people thought I should have given my son up because I had him at 17. I do hate it when people assume that teen parents CANT raise a child and adoption is the better answer. I am constantly told that my son is doing great and better than alot of kids born to parents who were in their late 20's. I honestly doubt anyone could have given him more love than I or his daddy have for him.

    I guess what I'm saying is that for the most part, you are right. Adoption isn't always the answer. Matter of fact, I always tell people that they should wait until at least halfway through their pregnancy to make a decision on one way or another. So much can change after feeling the first kicks and seeing the baby on an ultrasound. However, it is a better option for those who know they don't want or can't care for a baby. Better than trying to raise a child that they would resent or aborting.

  • 1 decade ago

    well since i was adopted I can tell you I didn't have a fairytale life but I had a good life. No one has a fairytale life whether adopted or not. I really don't think anyone is suggesting that adoption leads to a fairytale life. A lot of the time people are suggesting adoption either as an alternative to abortion or when it is clear the baby would be born to someone not ready to parent. I think your assumptions that a child born and given up for adoption would lead a life of foster care or "go through the system" is a little inaccurate. While there are those that end up with abusive parents (and that is clearly awful) it isn't as common as you make it sound. No one is saying giving a child up for adoption is easy either. Sometimes it is determining what is best for the baby not what is best for the mother. I think only women who are ready to do so and feel it is right should give their children up for adoption, but no one believes even in that situation it is easy.

    EDIT**Gouhly05 makes a good point by the way. Perspective adoptive parents are put under the microscope and are expected to jump through tons of hoops before being approved for adoption. They not only have to prove they are financially stable enough but also they could provide a stable enviornment for the adoptive child. What scrutiny does someone not adopting go through..NONE. Just because you can physically have a child doesn't always mean you should. That being said again...only women who feel it is right should give their child up for adoption.

    Source(s): mother of 2/ adult adoptee
  • 1 decade ago

    An adopted child has the same chance as any other child to live a fairytale life. In some respects, since it is so difficult to adopt, maybe an even better chance as the parents will have had to overcome many obstacles and have been closely scrutinized (one would hope anyway). They certainly stand a better chance than if they are killed before having the opportunity.

  • 1 decade ago

    No, not all adopted children have a fairy tale life...but at least they get to have a life. That is more than they get if they are aborted. Life is not a fairy tale for anyone, adopted or not. Kids can be just as easily abused or mistreated by biological parents as they can be adopted parents. There is always a chance but in my opinion, it is worth it to allow the child to live.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • C J
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    I have 2 adopted children in addition to my biological children. My kids came to me through the foster care system because they were given up by their parents. You are right, it is not sa cut and dry as others make it out to be. There are absolutely lots of loving families out there who would take care of that child well but my kids went through hell before I got them. My adopted son was abused as an infant. As a toddler... I just cant even talk about the things that happened its too painful.

    I was a surrogate mother too... for a friend. Let me tell you, its the hardest thing in the world to give a child up.

    As far as the abortion thing, if a mother wants to have the baby and give it up, fine, but I dont think that anyone has the right to push adoption on someone. Every woman has the right to choose what to do with her body, everyone else just needs to stay out of it.

  • 1 decade ago

    No, adopted children do not have fairytale lives. But they have a shot at living a NORMAL life instead of being the long-suffering child of someone who probably can't take care of herself, much less a baby. I want to cry just thinking about these poor kids whose moms are practically babies themselves.

    The horrible "foster" scenario you're describing is rarer than tv would lead you believe. And babies who are given up by their mothers often spend little or no time in state care since they are in such demand by childless couples. Other children, those who are taken from their parents because they are being abused or neglected, are often far better off in foster care than at their previous homes.

    I'm sure it's heartbreaking to part with a child after carrying him for 9 months (as a mother of 2, I have trouble imagining doing it). But there's a point at which keeping a baby you can't care for out of sentimental attachement becomes selfish because it isn't in the best interest of the child.

  • show
    Lv 4
    5 years ago

    I dont agree on abortion. Ive seen the unquestionably operation ensue and its disgusting and heartbreaking the way it takes place and it makes me under no circumstances prefer to have one. If a woman is pregnant and doesnt prefer the new child then they can provide it up for adoption. you rather cant say that its incorrect to hold a new child into the international and only assume its existence is going to be depressing and terrible. you only do no longer comprehend that. i might say that abortion is a sort of homicide. Its nevertheless a existence and you recognize its a existence so how the heck is it no longer homicide? you're killing yet another human. however if or no longer its concepts has progressed or no longer, it is going to be a human so which you're taking that away. i'm open minded approximately it nevertheless, as people have distinctive circumstances and motives as to why they abort, yet ordinary i do no longer agree on it yet i might continually help somebody in the event that they chosen to do it, yet me individually would not.

  • 1 decade ago

    I was reading something in a magazine the other day that they have found that among serial killers, a higher proportion of them than is statistically explainable were adopted as children. In some of them, it played a direct part in their sickness - like the Son of Sam, who killed couples in parked cars because he believed that's how he was conceived and that his mother threw him away.

    I think you bring up a very good point. It's not as simple as the movie Juno makes it out to be to give your child into a loving home.

  • 1 decade ago

    I don't believe that any child, adopted or not will live a fairy tale life. That's bunk.

    Life is full of hardships and sorrows regardless of what you do. But to take that innocent human life, no matter the circumstances of it's creation and determine whether it lives or dies is wrong.

  • mindi
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago

    nicole richie was adopted.. im not saying she had a fairytale life but she was adopted into a rich family and became famous

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.