Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Anonymous
Anonymous asked in Society & CultureReligion & Spirituality · 1 decade ago

Are Christians allowed their own take on things?

I asked a question originally as to why Christians quote from the bible and not from the heart but the answers were a bit obscure from some. They seem to see the bible as some sort of workshop manual to which to refer people for the opinion of Jesus and not their own.

I see religion and belief systems as something from the heart, not something written by someone else and I have difficulty with people who cannot give their own answer to a question. If I wanted the opinion of Jesus to my question I would look at the Bible. When I want the opinion of a Christian, I am asking what is in their own hearts, not what the book says.

Or are they so brainwashed they are not allowed an opinion? Or are they so brainwashed that their opinion is word for word as that which is in the bible. Does the doctrine to which they adhere forbid creative thought?

18 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I'm a Christian and think what I like to think. Jesus wasn't bound by the influences of predujices and hatreds of other people or religious "leaders". He didn't wait for his pastor or preacher to tell him what to do, what to believe, or who to vote for. He knew his own path and he walked it.

    I think that some groups of Christians - especially the right-wing/evangelical chaps in the US - tend to believe what they are told and do what they are told to do by whatever church authority they have been indoctrinated in to. Humans tend to do what they are told by human authority figures - that's a flaw of human conditioning in all walks of life. I think that Jesus, back in the day, was trying to break people out of that mould and look at the important picture - God, forgiveness, love etc. Sadly, when you are taught or exposed to a limited way of thinking or belief system, then you will use whatever tactics and tools you have at your disposal to defend it. This generally means using the same methods of repetition and selective bible thumping to get the message you have been taught.

  • 1 decade ago

    Let me ask you this question- let us say that you are a doctor. And a patient comes in your office and has some disease- where do you get your info for helping cure that disease? From yourself of a medical book? Hopefully you will know your the information that is in medical books, or your 6-8 years of education would be for naught. However when it comes to the Bible- we as Christians go to it , because it is actually the WORD OF OUR GOD. Brainwashed, no. IS a doc brainwashed because they go to medical books- of course not. Religion is man's attempt to find God. A relationship is God's way to reach down to man through Christ- this is what the bible leads all too. A Christian cannot separate from what Jesus says, because a Christian is a, or should be, a devoted follower of Christ

  • 1 decade ago

    I actually see the opposite, I see so many offshoots of Christianity, forcing their own doctrines that aren't even what the bible states.

    Christians MUST agree on the central theme, Jesus is God, Jesus died for our sins, Rose on the 3rd day and by accepting Christ you are forgiven of those sins and will spend eternity with God.

    That is Christianity.

    Its when ppl's opinions get in the way, that we get some freaky religions going on, that are totally astray from God's Word.

  • Guvo
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago

    Much of Christianity will say they have freedom in Christ. However, their thoughts and opinions are put in check by what they find in the Bible. Or rather, by someone else's interpretation of it. A lot of Christianity is merely the bandwagon approach. They want to feel they are a part of a new movement for God, and thus they let these new ideas become a part of themselves. Much akin to the way priests in Biblical times created their own laws, passing them off as God's laws. I once heard a preacher describe the situation as thus: God gave his laws. These are symbolized as pits in the ground. The priests were to teach the people not to fall into these pits (sins). So they came up with their own laws, building on God's laws, to build a fence around the pit. And then built fences around the fence. Now, surely, no one would fall into God's pits. But the priests considered crossing a fence as sin, and thus made God's laws a burden on the people. This is why Jesus was not pleased with the priesthood, because they made it so difficult to follow "God's laws" that people were disheartened.

    I think this is what a lot of Christianity does these days. It says "I have this cutesy new catchphrase. You should use it too or you don't love God." Then when you don't use it, you are ostracized and to them "God doesnt mean a lot to him because he won't 'give this thought up' for God (for my view of God)".

    Some churches, however, do encourage free thinking. I think notably of the United Methodist and the Community of Christ churches. It seems they allow you to figure out what a relationship with God means to you, instead of telling you "this is how you have to have a relationship with God."

    What a kind of life...freedom in flesh, shackles on your mind...

    Blessings in the Light of Christ!

    ~Embracing my Pangelism

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    I think you are trying to confuse religion with spirituality. Religion sets up the rules for life and prayer and worship within the religion in question. Personal spirituality is more individual, inner personal development within whatever religious path and the relationship between the individual and their chosen deity. Some never get past the following of the rules part and start working on the personal part. Sometimes I really do wonder if some people are so afraid to see and understand and accept what's inside that they really rather stick with the book.

  • 1 decade ago

    Christians are urged to read the bible themselves and see what it say. (Acts 17:10-12).

    The bible is the inspired Word of God (2 Timothy 3:16-17).

    Intellectual belief is not sufficient, nor can we go by ow feelings which can lead us astray. (John 8:31-32) Sincerity does not equal truth; religious people can be wrong.

    What is in the heart of man can be evil (Mark 7:20-23).

    An intellectual grasp of the freedom and obedience found in the bible is possible, but not by disregarding the very word itself. What you are suggesting is give in to man's selfish opinions and desires because "they seem right" or "I don't think that's necessary." In essence, you are asking God to give up some of His authority, when to be a true follower of Christ, God asks you to voluntarily to submit to His authority.

  • Roslyn
    Lv 4
    5 years ago

    They should be allowed to teach ANYTHING thing they want as long as it does not deter or prevent pupils from being productive members of society or grow into natural adult knowledge. HOWEVER, if the school wants to be state accredited or have it pupils recognized with colleges, etc, then the school needs to meet the state and/or federal requirements for curriculum. There are many public school that "write their own curriculum" but it has to meet state standards. The Christian schools also have to meet state standards if they want their degree to be recognized officially by the state. Schools and individual teachers will ALWAYS whether public or private "teach" things intentionally or unintentially outside state accrediation standards.

  • FROG E
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    I am a Christian...I quote from the bible because I know that there is power in the Word of God. The bible is written in a way that nonbelievers will not understand, but it makes so much sense to believers.......

  • 1 decade ago

    I think we are allowed much freedom of thought in things not directly (or indirectly) contravening Scripture. It would be ludicrous to claim belief in the Bible and then run with whatever flits across the mind.

  • 1 decade ago

    People quote the bible at you, but the bible in another part will say the opposite, so I think you can use your heart. Especially as the bible might well be translated wrong.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.